Industrial X‑ray inspection vs. industrial computed tomography

GET YOUR INSPECTION DONE – Anywhere. Anytime. Fast.
Both indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion and indus­tri­al com­pu­ted tomo­gra­phy are among the ima­ging methods used in mate­ri­als test­ing. But how do they dif­fer and when should which inspec­tion method be used? 

Industrial X‑ray inspection 

Non-des­truc­ti­ve mate­ri­als test­ing using X‑rays is used to visua­li­se inter­nal struc­tures of mate­ri­als such as metals, pla­s­tics, cera­mics and com­po­si­tes. X‑ray images are two-dimen­sio­nal and show the absorp­ti­on of X‑rays by the mate­ri­al, reve­al­ing infor­ma­ti­on about the den­si­ty, thic­k­ness and shape of objects. X‑rays are often used to iden­ti­fy defects such as cracks, poro­si­ty or inclu­si­ons in mate­ri­als and are wide­ly used in many indus­tri­al appli­ca­ti­ons, such as qua­li­ty con­trol of welds, cas­tings or elec­tro­nic components.

AI-based sys­tems can be used in auto­ma­ted X‑ray inspec­tion sys­tems to detect and ana­ly­se defects. Spe­cial algo­rith­ms are trai­ned to reco­g­ni­se and clas­si­fy dif­fe­rent types of defects.

Riss im Krümmer wird mit dem zerstörungsfreien Prüfverfahren industrielle CT sichtbar

Non-des­truc­ti­ve mate­ri­als test­ing using X‑rays is used to visua­li­se inter­nal struc­tures of mate­ri­als such as metals, pla­s­tics, cera­mics and com­po­si­tes. X‑ray images are two-dimen­sio­nal and show the absorp­ti­on of X‑rays by the mate­ri­al, reve­al­ing infor­ma­ti­on about the den­si­ty, thic­k­ness and shape of objects. X‑rays are often used to iden­ti­fy defects such as cracks, poro­si­ty or inclu­si­ons in mate­ri­als and are wide­ly used in many indus­tri­al appli­ca­ti­ons, such as qua­li­ty con­trol of welds, cas­tings or elec­tro­nic components.

AI-based sys­tems can be used in auto­ma­ted X‑ray inspec­tion sys­tems to detect and ana­ly­se defects. Spe­cial algo­rith­ms are trai­ned to reco­g­ni­se and clas­si­fy dif­fe­rent types of defects.

Riss im Krümmer wird mit dem zerstörungsfreien Prüfverfahren industrielle CT sichtbar

Industrial computed tomography 

Indus­tri­al com­pu­ted tomo­gra­phy is an advan­ced method that uses a com­bi­na­ti­on of X‑rays and com­pu­ter algo­rith­ms to crea­te three-dimen­sio­nal images of mate­ri­als. CT scan­ners cap­tu­re a varie­ty of X‑ray images from dif­fe­rent angles around the mate­ri­al and then use spe­cial soft­ware to recon­s­truct the­se images into a detail­ed three-dimen­sio­nal repre­sen­ta­ti­on of the mate­ri­al. Indus­tri­al CT makes it pos­si­ble to ana­ly­se inter­nal struc­tures of mate­ri­als in high reso­lu­ti­on and crea­te 3D models to visua­li­se com­plex geo­me­tries, defects and inter­nal fea­tures of com­pon­ents or work­pie­ces. With CT, much more data can be coll­ec­ted about the com­po­nent. This makes it pos­si­ble to bet­ter assess com­po­nent qua­li­ty. X‑rays, for exam­p­le, can quick­ly reach their limits when over­lay­ing geo­me­tries, struc­tures or defects. CT, on the other hand, plays to its strengths here and is thus par­ti­cu­lar­ly sui­ta­ble for safe­ty-rele­vant com­pon­ents. Due to the high accu­ra­cy of indus­tri­al CT, it is often used in non-des­truc­ti­ve test­ing (NDT) to check dimen­si­ons, inspect assem­blies and joints or iden­ti­fy defects such as cracks, poro­si­ty, del­a­mi­na­ti­on and inclu­si­ons in com­plex com­pon­ents or com­po­si­te mate­ri­als. Indus­tri­al CT is used in various indus­tries such as aero­space, auto­mo­ti­ve, elec­tro­nics and medical.

Simi­lar to indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion, AI-based sys­tems can be used in indus­tri­al CT to auto­ma­te the eva­lua­ti­on of CT results and thus signi­fi­cant­ly speed up the inspection.

Fehlerschwerpunktanalyse von Poren und Lunkern - Zerstörungsfreie Prüfung von Leichtmetallguss mittels CT Messtechnik
Prüfung additiv gefertigter Bauteile - Aluminium Radträger

Features X‑ray examination and CT at a glance

Indus­tri­al X‑ray inspection Indus­tri­al com­pu­ted tomography
Two-dimen­sio­nal Three-dimen­sio­nal
Mea­su­re­ment in pixels Mea­su­re­ment in voxels
Fas­ter scan­ning speed than CT Slower scan­ning speed than X‑ray
Ide­al for flat com­pon­ents with few geometries Ide­al for more com­plex and/or round components 

When is which test procedure worthwhile? 

The choice of test method depends, of cour­se, on the spe­ci­fic requi­re­ments and the available resour­ces. Nevert­hel­ess, it can be said in gene­ral terms in which cases which test­ing method makes more sense.

If the­re are flat com­pon­ents wit­hout com­plex geo­me­try that need to be inspec­ted quick­ly, indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion may be a good choice. Com­plex and detail­ed or safe­ty-rele­vant com­pon­ents that requi­re hig­her accu­ra­cy should be inspec­ted with indus­tri­al CT. This pro­vi­des valuable 3D infor­ma­ti­on about the com­pon­ents. Thus, mea­su­re­ments in depth are pos­si­ble, which has the advan­ta­ge that, for exam­p­le, it is pos­si­ble to detect whe­ther a defect is rele­vant or not in machi­ned sur­faces. In addi­ti­on, indus­tri­al com­pu­ted tomo­gra­phy makes it pos­si­ble to mea­su­re hid­den con­tours such as wall thic­k­nes­ses or chan­nel dia­me­ters. It also pro­vi­des important infor­ma­ti­on on whe­ther are­as of the com­po­nent are over­laid by other geo­me­tries with hig­her den­si­ty, such as seals in assem­bly inspec­tions.
Indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion, on the other hand, can only pro­vi­de the infor­ma­ti­on that a defect is pre­sent in all the­se examp­les; more detail­ed infor­ma­ti­on about the defect is dif­fi­cult to obtain with this inspec­tion method.

Fur­ther­mo­re, pri­ce is also a cri­ter­ion for deci­ding which non-des­truc­ti­ve test­ing method to use. Indus­tri­al CT is some­what more expen­si­ve than indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion. Howe­ver, cos­ts can be saved signi­fi­cant­ly with series test­ing using indus­tri­al CT. When choo­sing the method, cal­cu­la­te how expen­si­ve unde­tec­ted defects can beco­me. In some cases, such as with par­ti­cu­lar­ly lar­ge com­pon­ents, it may also make sen­se to cont­act a CT pro­vi­der. At Micro­vis­ta, for exam­p­le, we have often had cus­to­mers who had to cut up their com­pon­ents in order to be able to x‑ray them. For us, howe­ver, it was pos­si­ble to get them com­ple­te­ly into the CT wit­hout any problems.

In sum­ma­ry, it can be said that indus­tri­al X‑ray inspec­tion is rather well sui­ted for flat, simp­le com­pon­ents. Indus­tri­al CT, on the other hand, is ide­al for obtai­ning a detail­ed, three-dimen­sio­nal image and thus gai­ning more detail­ed infor­ma­ti­on about the qua­li­ty of the com­po­nent. With both methods, AI can be used to inspect lar­ge quan­ti­ties of com­pon­ents in a much shorter time at low cost.

Write a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other articles